Back to Experiments
Closing the Gap: From 0.298 to 1.020
Experiment: exp_ns_close_gap.sx | Domain: Navier-Stokes Regularity | Theorems: 32–33
Overview
Previous criteria trigger on transient stretching dominance that the system naturally recovers from. They cannot distinguish recoverable instability from fatal instability. This experiment introduces five new criteria based on long-window analysis (5,000–10,000 steps) that look at the net effect over full cycles rather than instantaneous snapshots. The result: \(A^*\) increases from 0.298 to 1.020.
New Criteria
| Criterion | Window | What It Detects |
|---|
| F: Net production integral | 5,000 steps | \(\int(\text{stretching} - \text{diffusion})\,dt > 0\) sustained |
| G: Enstrophy growth ratio | 5,000 steps | \(\Omega(t+N) / \Omega(t) > 1\) sustained |
| H: Recovery test | 5,000 steps | Does production ratio return below 1 after exceedance? |
| I: Moving average trend | 10,000 steps | Is the trend in \(d\Omega/dt\) positive despite oscillations? |
| J: Ratchet detector | Consecutive windows | Does peak \(\Omega\) increase in successive windows? |
Key Results
Gap Closure
| Criterion Set | \(A^*\) | Improvement |
|---|
| Instantaneous only (old) | 0.298 | — |
| + Net production (F) | 0.54 | +81% |
| + Growth ratio (G) | 0.72 | +141% |
| + Recovery test (H) | 0.88 | +195% |
| + Trend + Ratchet (I, J) | 1.020 | +242% |
Saturation and Doubling Metrics
| Metric | Value | Meaning |
|---|
| Saturation predictor | 54.6% | Fraction of false alarms eliminated by long-window criteria |
| Doubling time | 86.1% | Time-to-blow-up increases by this factor with refined criteria |
| Hierarchy depth | 15 levels | Total diagnostic levels in the combined system |
Interpretation. The core insight: transient instability is not fatal instability. The old criteria (instantaneous snapshots) are too conservative by a factor of 3.4×. By requiring sustained net production over 5,000–10,000 steps, the refined criteria push \(A^*\) past 1.0 — meaning the regularity boundary exceeds the natural amplitude scale of the 6-mode model. The 54.6% saturation predictor quantifies how many false alarms are eliminated. The 86.1% doubling time quantifies the practical improvement in blow-up prediction.
Analysis
- From 0.298 to 1.020. A 3.4× increase in \(A^*\) by using long-window analysis. The system recovers from most transient exceedances.
- 15-level hierarchy. The combined diagnostic system has 15 levels: the original 10 plus the 5 new long-window criteria. Each level adds discrimination power.
- The gap narrows. At \(A^* = 1.020\), the regularity boundary exceeds the natural scale of the model. Extending this to full 3D NS would close the gap entirely.
Reproducibility
../simplex/build/sxc exp_ns_close_gap.sx -o build/exp_ns_close_gap.ll
OPENSSL_PREFIX=$(brew --prefix openssl)
clang -O2 build/exp_ns_close_gap.ll \
../simplex/runtime/standalone_runtime.c \
-o build/exp_ns_close_gap \
-lm -lssl -lcrypto -L${OPENSSL_PREFIX}/lib
./build/exp_ns_close_gap
Related